Is Premier League Salary Cap Really A Viable Option?

It seems very rich that Chelsea Chairman Bruce Buck should call for a salary cap in the Premier League. After all, it was Bruce Buck, hired by Roman Abramovich in 2004 that offered massive salary’s to the likes of Andriy Shevchenko, John Terry and Frank Lampard. Should the Premier League really take the Chelsea man seriously. If Roman Abramovich had continued to spend such vast sums of money on Chelsea, and if Manchester City hadn’t been bought by the Abu Dhabi United Group Investment and Development Limited – do we really believe Bruce Buck would be making such statements. Of course not. The Chelsea Chairman is anxious of Manchester City’s spending power and would like to see it reined in to help Chelsea compete long term.

Though we shouldn’t be lectured by Bruce Buck or any of the money men at Chelsea, a salary cap is something that the Premier League ought to consider based on its own merits. With Uefa introducing the Financial Fair Play regulations from the 2013-2014 season, where clubs will have to break even or be excluded from European competition – is it now the time to introduce such measures. These seem very sensible measures set out by Uefa but will a salary cap really change anything for Europe’s top clubs. For example, Manchester United make record losses. A salary cap would do very little to adjust the books because of the debt placed on the club. The same can be said for Barcelona. The club have massive debts, again a salary cap wouldn’t even dent the money owed by the club.

The salary cap could danger the quality of players in the English game. If the Premier League were to introduce such a cap then it must be a fear that players will simply move to countries outside of the cap. We would all love to believe that we have some of the worlds top players because of the standard of our game. Simply, this isn’t true. Our top clubs pay huge sums of money to attract and keep the top players. Hypothetically, if a salary cap was introduced last week, do we truly believe that Wayne Rooney would have signed a new deal at Manchester United?

[divider]

A salary cap, though a noble effort to bring English football into the real world – unfortunately it would damage the quality of the players in our league. Football clubs are private businesses and have the right to pay their employees what ever they feel is appropriate. Some clubs have been responsible and some have been so very irresponsible. However, this is the free market and as frustrating as it is to see young footballers role into clubs in top of the range sports cars while hundreds are made redundant, this is the price we all have to pay the success the league has had over the years.

The situation changes if Fifa were to introduce a worldwide salary cap. Clubs would have to be more responsible and players salary’s would be brought into the real world. This could bridge the gap between the superstars and the fans who pay so much each week to see them. On average Premier League clubs are paying 67% of turnover on wages and this financial in balance needs to be addressed. A salary cap would help but if agents are demanding such huge sums for their players, what choice to clubs really have. Before a salary cap, a code of conduct for agents and football club owners needs to be drawn up.

A salary cap is without doubt what the majority of football fans want to see. However, what fans also want to see is the best player possible playing at their club – and they cost money. We have to accept that with one we lose the other. What are our priories? Top players or bringing the game back to some sort of noble profession. The problem is we have allowed football clubs to offer such huge sums of money for too long now – can we really put an end to it in one swoop. A salary cap is dangerous but does need to be explored to see if it is applicable. Football needs to look at other sports and make sure we understand the pros and cons. If we encourage responsibility and better conduct by all, we will have a better game for it. A salary cap should only be introduced if it could guarantee better practice in the game.

Like what you read? Subscribe to my RSS feed or follow me on twitter here

Fancy playing your mates every week in a Premium Fantasy Football game?

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Chris Kirkland poised for Leicester loan

Wigan Athletic manager Roberto Martinez has confirmed that goalkeeper Chris Kirkland is poised to join Championship outfit Leicester City on loan.

The 29-year-old England international has lost his first-team spot with the Latics to loanee Ali Al Habsi and will head to his hometown club to help them try and challenge for promotion to the Premier League.

Martinez told the Evening Post:"Things have been delayed by Chris' bug, but we will be sitting down to have a chat about the situation.

"He got the bug last Thursday night and couldn't travel with the team to Old Trafford, but he trained all right on Monday.

"He's lost a little bit of weight, but he'll hopefully regain that very quickly. Now he's over the bug, we'll look into what we can do to help him enjoy his football.

"He needs to be playing football and be able to maintain that sharpness that you only get when you're playing regular football.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

"That's important, because we'll need him to be ready whenever he gets an opportunity to play for Wigan Athletic."Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email

Tottenham Taylor hopes torn

Any hopes that Harry Redknapp may have had to try and land Newcastle defender Steven Taylor look set to be dashed.

The Magpies are thought to be close to tying him down to a new deal, with his current contract set to end in June.

Taylor was transfer listed during the summer as contract talks hit an impasse but reports claim Newcastle have offered the defender improved terms to remain at St James' Park.

It has been claimed the club have offered Taylor over £40,000 a week to remain at Newcastle in a bid to fend off interest from Spurs and Everton, who are thought to be eager to sign him as a free agent in the summer.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Tottenham face Birmingham City at St Andrews on Saturday afternoon hoping to keep their bid for a top four place on track. Spurs are currently in fifth place, one point behind Manchester City in fourth.Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email

A Big Club? Maybe, But They Are Certainly The Biggest Joke In The League

Just who exactly do Newcastle United think they are?  Having last won a meaningful trophy sometime in the dark ages they still consider themselves a ‘big club’.  But what makes a big club?

Does having an overly-attacking team and squandering a huge lead in the title race sometime in the 1990’s really constitute a big club?  Does being the last team to win the Championship make them a big club?  Or does stupidly sacking their manager when he’s doing a decent job make them one of the big boys?

Chris Hughton was treated appallingly.  As he left the club – with a fair amount of grace and decorum it must be said – he thanked those who needed to be thanked and went quietly on his way, hopefully he’ll end up in another job soon, preferably at a club that appreciated his hard work and potential.  And it’s not just Mike Ashley, the North East has been a deluded part of the footballing country for years now.

But Newcastle always do this.  There was the Kevin Keegan saga (which one?), the Dennis Wise fiasco, the employment of characters such as Allardyce and Shearer and now when they accidentally come across a manager of calibre and experience – and one who has done the job that has been asked of him – they sack him.  But why??

Newcastle will never achieve anything as long as they have this attitude.  Just because they have a big ground and a loyal fanbase does not give them the divine right to play in the Premiership and certainly doesn’t give them the right to win or even compete for trophies.

The days of Shearer are gone.  The days of Tino Asprilla and David Ginola are gone.  Even the days of Bobby Robson are gone (R.I.P. by the way, a true gentleman of the game and still sorely missed), and now the era of being a mid-table Premiership club (at best) is here to stay.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

11th in the league is roughly where you belong, get used to it.

FIVE things we learnt about Manchester United this afternoon

It wasn’t pretty but Sir Alex Ferguson won’t mind one iota as the three points maintains United’s position at the top of the Premier League table.

The game was scrappy and the Red Devils certainly struggled to find any rhythm on what was a heavy pitch. Javier Hernandez came off the bench to grab the winner and it’s a goal that brought welcome relief to Sir Alex Ferguson.

So how did Manchester United fans feel about today, and what are the five things we learnt about the Red Devils this afternoon?

[divider]

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

[divider]

Holy Crap – it’s live fantasy football! Become part of Chelsea v Aston Villa and play Picklive for FREE Watch and bet live – spices up any game!

A necessary evil? Or yet another dumb rule?

Safety. It’s an ever present – and mostly legitimate – excuse for many of the lamented restrictions in the modern game. All seater stadiums? Safety. No alcohol in the ground and dry areas for crunch matches? Safety. The continued unemployment of Iain Dowie’s face? Safety.

Whilst comedian Stewart Lee may be right in his assessment that a whole generation of people have confused political correctness with health and safety legislation when they complain of a rise in the madness of things, there can be no confusion as to why a country with a long and famous track record of crowd trouble and an even more inglorious history of stadium tragedy should be so hung up on this particular facet.

Many, if not most fans will point to Germany as an example of how a standing area can be implemented safely and efficiently within the modern mind set, not least Manchester United’s traveling support, who continue to have their allocations diminished – to little avail – for their steadfast refusal to sit down at matches. In fact if I had my way the German model would be the totem by which all football leagues are run, from stadia to fan ownership to their baffling admiration for David Hasselhoff. But the fact remains that whilst the worst horrors of the 80s remain in the public consciousness the political climate will never be susceptible to such ideas. Even if the most vocal opposition comes from the type of Daily Mail reading campaign junkies with little knowledge of the actual practicalities or the game itself. It won’t happen people. Sorry, tough.

However as with all decisions born from the best intentions, it’s inevitable that the fringe effects will cause controversy, and such an effect hit the headlines a mere few weeks ago with the sending off of West Ham’s Frederic Piquionne.

After scoring what he thought would be a deserved late winner for the beleaguered London club, Piquionne ran to the crowd, vaulted the advertising hoardings and embraced a few over excited cockneys in the front row. So far, so natural you may assume. Except that the Frenchman’s actions were deemed in breach of the rules on crowd incitement, and after picking up a booking earlier in the half, he was sent off for the heinous crime of over enjoying himself.

The natural fan reaction to this – I would assume (and you know they say about assumption’s progeny) – is one of exasperated distain. A stupid, officious rule dreamt up by the game’s out of touch suited bureaucrats (which I feel compelled to tell you my spell check suggested should be Bearcats – a far more exciting term than they deserve.) Political correctness gone mad as it were. But the other side of the spade isn’t quite as obvious as that mixed metaphor. There are two sides to every coin.

Attempting to prevent the crowd from surging is not a pointless objective. In keeping with the theme of confusion, it’s pertinent to point out in a Stewart Lee-ian type way that this is not the same as the rule punishing players for taking their shirts off, though it is often bundled together. That almost certainly (well, just certainly) is pointless, officious and as daft as a bat in a bag of nuts. The reason Piquionne was booked however was distinctly different, reprimanded for the possible danger from crushing he could’ve placed those in the stands.

Putting aside for a second the obvious retort that the striker was aware of the rule and thus deserving of any punishment given (something that fails to take into account the often inequitable behavioral effects of scoring a crucial late goal in a football match) it’s more pertinent is to discuss just how much danger his actions could have actually caused. The main causes of crushing in the bygone days of terraced football were overcrowding and enclosure. The implementation of all seater stadiums has reduced the possibility of the former all but entirely (in Premier League grounds at least) and no grounds in England – to my knowledge – still retain any fencing or gating to keep the crowd from the pitch, with that function now performed by stewards and occasionally police, for the very reasons mentioned. It may seem churlish to dismiss the likely hood of such events, especially since we can all see the possibility of a child being caught up in the surge and pressed against, or even flung over the seat in front, but realistically the commotion caused would be little different to that created by the goal itself. It’s a question of how far we take it.

Away sections are often more boisterous than home crowds as it is and if we’re really going to hammer down the prospects of endangerment then we might as well stop goal celebrations all together and return to the pre-war days of polite applause. Yes we have to start somewhere, but it’s that age-old reasoning of common sense that stands out most prominently. Piquionne’s actions were unlikely to cause a riot, or even much raucous behaviour beyond the first few rows. Even if they had instigated a mild pitch invasion, the event would’ve been curtailed quickly and the ease at which the fans could reach the pitch and escape from the mele would’ve instantly diluted the prospects of danger, as they would’ve in many tragedies.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Perhaps I’m being too soft, or irresponsible, but there needs to be some leeway for exuberance at football surely? The passion of the game is precisely what sets it apart from others as the most beloved throughout the world. The instant tribal emotions it instills are amongst it’s primary appeals.

I am not, and never will be, one of those who bemoans the lack of atmosphere the modern game and all it’s measures have brought about as an unnecessary evil. It was very necessary. But are we in danger of going too far, just a little, with measures like this? Why is it so hard to judge the difference between an act of emotion and genuine incitement? Why does the argument of consistency mean we should abandon perspective and relativity? It’s political correctness gone mad I tell you. Or is it?

You can follow Oscar on Twitter here http://twitter.com/oscarpyejeary where you can discuss the week’s fiercely debated political issues in a variety of silly hats.

Arsenal take transfer gamble, Saint wise to veto Arsenal DEAL, Jack Wilshere wasted – Best of AFC

A second half capitualtion of mass proportion saw Arsenal throw away a golden opportunity to close the gap at the top of the table. Arsene Wenger will be privately seething at the Gunners failure to see the game out, especially given the subsequent United result at the West Midlands this evening.

At FFC this week we have seen a mixed bag of Arsenal blogs that includes an unnecessary gamble that Gunners didn’t need to take; Wenger puts an end to keeping debate, while the big question the Arsenal fans will be asking.

We also look at the best Arsenal articles around the web this week.

*

The Premiership’s Greatest Foreign XI of all time?

Arsenal’s very own ‘Mr Marmite’

The big question Arsenal fans will be asking…

TEN things we learned from the January Transfer Window

An unnecessary gamble that Arsenal didn’t need to take

TEN things we can guarantee on Transfer deadline day

Is Waving An Imaginary Yellow Card Really That Bad?

Wenger finally puts an end to the Arsenal debate

Arsenal, Spurs, Liverpool…should they bide their time before the step up?

Arsenal star will be wasted…well in my opinion

The real transfer winners and losers this January

Time to change the disciplinary system in football?

*Best of WEB*

Arsene Wenger is influenced by the fans, it’s official and the ballot. What a joke Arsenal. – Le Grove

Spur him on or push him out?? Even Denilson and Hleb were on his back! – Highbury House

Mistaking Desperation For Intent – A Cultured Left Foot

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Is Cesc Fabregas really a contentious figure as many claim? – Gunnersphere

No signings the right call – Online Gooner

[divider]

Click on image below to see a gallery of Ronaldo’s latest lady

[divider]

FA Cup preview: City eye Notts redemption

Manchester City host League One side Notts County in an FA Cup fourth-round replay on Sunday, with Fulham and Arsenal also in action.Roberto Mancini’s expensively assembled side were fortunate to escape with a draw in January’s fourth-round match at Meadow Lane, with new signing Edin Dzeko the hero for City, scoring an equaliser in the 80th minute to secure a 1-1 draw.Mancini rested star striker Carlos Tevez for the clash, but the Italian manager’s willingness to use the Argentine in their Europa League first leg against Aris Thessaloniki on Tuesday in Greece could see the English Premier League’s second-highest goal scorer this season appear at Eastlands on Sunday.But vying for a spot up front for City will be Italian import Mario Balotelli, who is on the brink of a return from injury. “By the time the weekend comes, he will have another week of training under his belt and will be available for selection if the manager picks him,” First team coach David Platt told the Manchester Evening News.Paul Ince’s Notts County brought up their first win in seven matches in all competitions with a 2-0 league victory over Colchester on Tuesday, a necessary morale booster before their trip to Manchester.City, meanwhile, will be riled by their loss to rivals Manchester United on Sunday in the Premier League, which all but ended their title aspirations.They will be without Adam Johnson and Nigel de Jong on Sunday.Notts County midfielder Neal Bishop will be hoping to replicate his goal against City from their initial clash last month, while other dangerous players for the visitors include the Premier League-experienced Lee Hughes (formerly of West Bromwich Albion), Stephen Darby (Liverpool) and Jon Harley (Fulham/Chelsea).In Sunday’s other matches, Bolton Wanderers travel to Fulham’s Craven Cottage for an all-Premier League fifth-round match.Arsenal, fresh from their 2-1 Champions League round-of-16 first-leg victory over Barcelona, travel to Brisbane Road to take on League One side Leyton Orient.Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger is likely to make significant changes to his regular line-up as the team attempt to maintain a challenge in four competitions this season.

FA Cup preview: Crawley aim for biggest scalp yet

Manchester United take on non-league Crawley Town in the pick of the FA Cup fifth round matches on Saturday.No non-league side have ever been beyond this stage of the competition, and if Crawley progress to the last eight at Old Trafford, it would be a shock of seismic proportions.Crawley, who have been in existence since 1896, are, like United, nicknamed the Red Devils and doing well in their league, the Blue Square Premier.They have already beaten Swindon Town, Derby County and Torquay United in the FA Cup, but even if Sir Alex Ferguson sends out an under-strength side, his team should have more than enough firepower.United, who have lifted the trophy 11 times and currently sit on top of the English Premier League, beat Liverpool in the third round, came from behind to defeat Southampton 2-1 last time out, and will be buoyed by last Saturday’s derby defeat of Manchester City.There could be more realistic chances of a giant-killing in Saturday’s two other Fifth Round ties.Birmingham City, who have already reached the Carling Cup final, host League One strugglers Sheffield Wednesday at St Andrews.But with that Carling Cup final just a week away, and Birmingham looking over their shoulders in the league, they could easily become distracted.The FA Cup has certainly given Wednesday fans something to cheer about of late – the Owls have not won in the league in 2011, but have knockout wins over Bristol City and Hereford United.League One leaders Brighton, flying high under former Chelsea player Gus Poyet, travel to Stoke City.They have already caused two upsets this season, knocking out Championship sides Portsmouth and Watford, and will be hoping to spring another surprise at the Britannia Stadium.Tony Pulis’ Stoke lie 10th in the EPL and with top flight football almost guaranteed next season, they can turn their full attention to the Cup.A fixture pile up means that Chelsea and Everton will play their fourth round replay on Saturday, with a trip to Reading awaiting the winners.Back in January, Everton led through a Louis Saha strike before Salomon Kalou salvaged a 1-1 draw for Chelsea.Last year’s winners will be without cup-tied Fernando Torres, so Didier Drogba will return to the starting line-up.Chelsea have only won five of their last 15 fixtures in all competitions, and were held to a 1-1 draw with Everton at Stamford Bridge in December in the league.Everton’s form is patchy as well – they sit just three points above the relegation zone, and Saha could miss out after pulling a hamstring in training.

Wenger keen to sign Mendy, An astute SIGNING by Arsenal, British media buys into Gunners’ smokescreen – Best of AFC

It is the title or nothing for Arsene Wenger as Arsenal crashed out of their second cup competition in a week to add to their cup final loss against Birmingham City. In many ways it could prove a blessing in disguise for the Gunners who have the league solely to concentrate on, while United still have three competitions to contend with.

At FFC this week we have seen a mixed bag of Arsenal blogs that includes the media buying into Gunners’ smokescreen; time for Bendtner to deliver and the worst thing that Wenger could have said.

We also look at the best Arsenal articles around the web this week.

*

WAG Weekly – Alexander bags himself a beauty!

The Greatest Premier League XI of all time?

Arsenal’s Worst XI of recent memory?

*

British Media buys into Arsenal smokescreen

Arsenal find out this ‘joke’ isn’t funny anymore

Time for Arsenal star to finally walk the walk

An Arsenal burden that needs to be shared?

Much more for Arsenal than just 90 minutes of football

The worst thing Wenger could have said?

An astute signing by Arsenal, or destined to fail?

*Best of Web*

Jack The Giant Is Our True Captain – Online Gooner

Cesc takes responsibility for loss at Camp Nou, but who was truly at fault? – Gunnersphere

Arsenal blow it again. Forget the excuses. This was predictable. – Le Grove

Cesc Fabregas – You are an embarrassment!! – Highbury House

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

The Spirit Of Arsenal – A Cultured Left Foot

Wenger keen to sign French youth star Benjamin Mendy – Gunnersphere

[divider]

Click on image below to see a gallery of Christian’s lady wife

Game
Register
Service
Bonus